Monday, October 8, 2012

Krugman: If You are Not Awed by the Latest Employment Figures, Then You are "Deranged"

When Paul Krugman was awarded the Nobel Prize in economics four years ago, Donald Luskin wrote tongue-in-cheek that the committee from the Swedish central bank had given the honor to what essentially was a "dead economist."  Luskin's point was that Krugman a decade before had traded in his economist's hat for the headgear of a political operative, and today's column is a case-in-point.

Last week the U.S. Department of Labor announced that the nation's unemployment rate had fallen to 7.8 percent, and the same Paul Krugman who would excoriate the George W. Bush administration (which, truthfully, deserved to be excoriated) when unemployment was under six percent, now is undeniably giddy over the data:
On the employer side, the current numbers say that over the past year the economy added 150,000 jobs a month, and revisions will probably push that number up significantly. That’s well above the 90,000 or so added jobs per month that we need to keep up with population.
He goes on to claim that had Goldstein, er, the "scorched-earth Republicans," not sabotaged the whole recovery, we might be near-swimming in prosperity. Krugman declares:
...that’s the truth that the right can’t handle. The furor over Friday’s report revealed a political movement that is rooting for American failure, so obsessed with taking down Mr. Obama that good news for the nation’s long-suffering workers drives its members into a blind rage. It also revealed a movement that lives in an intellectual bubble, dealing with uncomfortable reality — whether that reality involves polls or economic data — not just by denying the facts, but by spinning wild conspiracy theories.

It is, quite simply, frightening to think that a movement this deranged wields so much political power.
So, there you have it. If you are not convinced that Operation Twist, QE Forever, massive subsidies to windmills and corn-based ethanol, inflation, and make-work schemes have not put us on the road to prosperity, then you not only are "deranged," but you are in league with Goldstein.

Let me put it another way: Does anyone think that if a Republican (Goldstein) were in office and unemployment was over 8 percent all during the person's time in office and the rate fell to 7.8 percent a month before the election, that Krugman would be claiming that the True Recovery had arrived? No, I didn't think so.

Friday, October 5, 2012

Plans and Economic Reality

For all of the talk from Keynesians that their goal is to help the private economy "gain traction," Keynesianism ultimately is about central government planning, be it monetary planning, government spending, or regulatory mandates. The ultimate mantra of the Keynesian is this: Statism equals prosperity.

Thus it is that in the wake of the Obama debate debacle, Paul Krugman has decided to go to war...over dueling medical plans, and his argument is this: Obama has a better "plan" than does Romney, and if Romney says otherwise, he is lying. One has to understand that what Krugman is arguing is that these plans are going to perform exactly as they are written, and that requires a huge stretch of the imagination.

When one peels away the rhetoric about the dueling "plans," one finds that the central assumption is that government central planning works. In Wonderland, we are supposed to believe that the Obama plan actually will result in expanded coverage at lower costs? Why? Because Obama says so. With the Romney plan, things will not turn out well? Why? Because Krugman says so.

Never before in economic history has government planning done what Krugman claims ObamaCare will do: create more need-fulfilling services while simultaneously using fewer per capita resources. That is the heart of the debate, not which candidate has the better central plan.

Krugman can throw out all of the ex ante projections he wants, but the point is that by expanding the regulatory and confiscatory state, and employing an army of bureaucrats to see that all of the jillions of rules are followed to the letter, ObamaCare -- or RomneyCare II, for that matter -- ultimately will result in higher real costs of medical care. And as people find that the heart of ObamaCare's "cost-cutting" measures really means denial of medical choices for those who are not politically-connected, the ensuing "crisis" will bring demands for even more government control.

The regulatory state is quite predictable in its outcomes, yet people continually go to the same dry well because that is what the Progressives who essentially control all of our major institutions claim will "solve" the latest set of problems. Whether the OC or RC plans are implemented, in the end we will find that central planning from Washington will mean deterioration of medical services.

As I see it, the real issue is not the red herring of whether Mitt Romney told the Truth According to Paul Krugman. No, the real issue is that Washington is embarking on a journey that will have outcomes that are much different -- and much worse -- than what is being promised. Paul Krugman is politically-connected and he is wealthy; he won't have to worry about being denied care.

But those people who are not in Krugman's privileged category are going to find that not only will the government actively restrict their medical care, it will do it in an iron-fisted way. Central planning is central planning, and all of the rhetoric in the world cannot change that hard and sad fact.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

Krugman Tell a Lie? Oh, Surely Not!

In a blog post following the first presidential debate, Paul Krugman insisted that while Obama did rather poorly, he spoke only the truth while Mitt Romney spoke only lies. Given that I cannot imagine the president or his main challenger telling the truth, I would say that Krugman was guilty of speaking only half a lie, but nonetheless, by insisting that Obama tells only the truth, that half was a whopper.

Krugman, being the political operative that he is, insisted in his latest column that the economy is not in any kind of crisis. In a recent speech in Europe, however, Krugman told a different story, warning of impending collapses if Europe continues its present course of what Krugman calls "austerity." What I find most interesting about his speech, however, is his insistence that the European Central Bank engage in what would be nothing more than a pure print-the-euro scheme, as though the "Zimbabwe Solution" would be sustainable. He declared that Europe must
...contain immediately the financial threat to troubled countries and stabilize yields on their borrowing, which in the end requires the ECB to be ready to be the lender of last resort and buy sovereign bonds.
Understand what he is saying. In effect, he is recommending that the European authorities create what would be an inflation crisis -- and that is what pure money printing schemes like this always create -- in order to solve the fiscal crisis. So, I guess that if Europeans are drowning in euros, they will forget that their economies are grinding to a halt. The Krugman "solution," or what we call the "Inflation Fairy."

Monday, October 1, 2012

Krugman: Nothing to See Here, Folks! The Economy is Doing Great!

Yes, yes, Paul Krugman's latest column is a stirring defense of the Welfare State, which in Wonderland is permanently sustainable because interest rates are low. And why are interest rates low? I think his former department chair, Ben Bernanke, might have something to do with that, but low rates certainly are not due to any increase in savings or positive long-term outlooks by investors.

Krugman writes:
...we are not facing any kind of fiscal crisis. Indeed, U.S. borrowing costs are at historic lows, with investors actually willing to pay the government for the privilege of owning inflation-protected bonds. So reducing the budget deficit just isn’t the top priority for America at the moment; creating jobs is. For now, the administration’s political capital should be devoted to passing something like last year’s American Jobs Act and providing effective mortgage debt relief. 
 Actually, an economy normally creates employment opportunities by creating new wealth, not printing money, but in Wonderland, the printing press is the real source of wealth and the more the Obama administration through Bernanke prints (and that essentially is what the guy is doing), the wealthier we are!

How do economies grow? Before the creation of Wonderland, they grew when entrepreneurs found ways to combine resources and factors of production in way that would enable them to move these factors and resources from lower-valued to higher-valued uses, as ultimately decided by people who purchased consumption goods. Over time, entrepreneurs found newer and better ways to apply these resources in a way in which we were able to produce more with less.

Even economists at one time believed that. Today, we have Nobel Prize-winning economists claim that economies grow via government spending, through vast subsidies given to industries run by people who are politically-connected to whomever is in power, and by keeping entrepreneurs from producing more wealth.

In Wonderland, "costs" simply are official price-denominated outlays that can be raised or lowered simply via government edict. As the Federal Reserve System quietly props up more banks and governments, we are told that Bernanke actually is creating a miracle world in which the Law of Opportunity Cost is repealed.

The real economy is doing very poorly, but Krugman and his friends in Washington, which has found itself in the position of becoming wealthier during this depression -- at the expense of the rest of the country -- are doing quite well, thank you. Federal workers are taking in more than ever, while the regulatory state grows and grows, while the police powers of the State of Wonderland increase.

Once upon a time, Washington would have been exposed for the parasitic economy it has become, but now that we are in the Age of Wonderland led by Really Smart People, Washington's new riches are seen as progress. Socialism comes to a grinding halt when, in Margaret Thatchers words, the socialists run out of other people's money to spend, but I guess we are not quite there yet.

You see, Krugman actually seems to believe that the "Social Safety Net" actually is a net creator, not a net consumer of wealth. It is economics turned upside down, but for the time being, the folks who believe we create new wealth by taxation, printing money, borrowing at record rates, restricting entrepreneurs, and promoting inflation have the microphone and they are not giving it up.

Monday, September 24, 2012

The Inflation Fairy

One of the most repeated themes in Paul Krugman's columns has been the ridicule of what he calls "The Confidence Fairy," which is in reference to Robert Higgs's theory that says "regime uncertainty" has a real effect upon present economic growth. However, because Krugman has no conception of capital investment (other than it brings spending) and does not have any understanding of the difference between the long and short run, he is intellectually ill-equipped to refute the Higgs thesis.

I bring this up because Krugman's latest column is more of the same: inflation and massive borrowing will solve all of our economic ills, and anything else is just something out of fairy tales. Now, I realize that Krugman is working with the Obama campaign to write columns critical of Mitt Romney, and part of his ridicule is of Romney's recent statements about market confidence; in other words, his primary goal is to attack Romney, not to increase public economic knowledge. However, he does bring up his whole "Confidence Fairy" line, and I think it is worth a look. He writes:
Back in 2010, as European nations began implementing savage austerity programs to placate bond markets, it was common for policy makers to deny that these programs would have a depressing effect. “The idea that austerity measures could trigger stagnation is incorrect,” insisted Jean-Claude Trichet, then the president of the European Central Bank. Why? Because these measures would “increase the confidence of households, firms and investors.”

At the time I ridiculed such claims as belief in the “confidence fairy.” And sure enough, austerity programs actually led to Depression-level economic downturns across much of Europe.

Yet here comes Mitt Romney, declaring, in effect, “I am the confidence fairy!”
 Where I agree with Krugman is that confidence, and especially any "confidence" that Romney could bring to the table, is a relative thing. Just because a supposed "pro-business" president is in the White House is not going to resurrect long-term capital investment and provide a lift for private enterprise. Business investors would have to see that there not only is a strong possibility of return on their investments, some of which may take years to come to fruition, but that there will not be the kind of "regime change" in Washington that either would forcibly confiscate those returns or change the rules of the game to where that original investment now becomes worthless. Robert Higgs says:
"Regime uncertainty" is the name I give to widespread fears that the nature of the economic order will be changed. This has to do mainly with fear that private-property rights will be altered for the worse by higher taxes, more costly regulation, more hostile treatment by government functionaries of all kinds, and perhaps outright confiscation of private property. When investors feel regime uncertainty, they are reluctant to make long-term investments, because they fear that they will be unable to receive the income those investments will generate and may even lose the capital itself. Between 1935 and 1940, many US investors feared that the market-oriented US economy was being transformed into fascism, socialism, or some other system dominated by the government.
I certainly believe that President Obama has firmly placed himself into the "Crony Capitalism" camp in which his government will subsidize and protect those business firms that are loyal to his administration, but will use tax laws, regulations, and verbal (and legal) bullying against anyone else who does not recognize the Greatness of Obama. Whether or not Mitt Romney can end such an order is an empirical question, although I don't think I would be willing to take a bet that he would.

Yet, Krugman does not even address that point. No, what Krugman claims will create confidence in the economy is inflation, which is why I call his "plan" to end the depression one that is based upon the Inflation Fairy. The claim by Krugman and his supporters is that should the Federal Reserve System link its efforts with the U.S. Government to directly inject new money via government spending, the new money magically will flow only to those industries that are depressed and bypass those areas of production that currently are producing at higher capacities.

I'm not sure how this is possible, but Krugman believes that the Inflation Fairy will be able to pull it off. You see, when the Inflation Fairy is at work, there never is any dislocation within price systems, as all factors automatically adjust perfectly to the changing conditions. Moreover, whenever business investors realize that inflation is on the horizon, they automatically will produce more goods and engage in capital investment because inflation always equals more aggregate demand, and aggregate demand means that everyone wants to buy everything.

When the Obama administration demands that capital gains tax rates be raised to the highest levels in four decades, the Inflation Fairy will ensure that such calls for widespread confiscation of property will have absolutely no effect upon business investment. Furthermore, if greedy private investors are put off by the fact that government is going to take nearly all of their economic profits, then the Inflation Fairy will ensure that government spending will take up the slack and employ everyone in meaningful jobs with high pay.

And so on. I marvel that Krugman continues either to create caricatures of the Higgs assertion of "Regime Uncertainty" while making wild claims about the Wonders and Greatness of the Inflation Fairy. The problem with Paul Krugman is not that he has become a partisan shill who coordinates his columns with the Obama presidential campaign.

No, the problem is that Krugman wants us to believe that when depression conditions occur, the Law of Scarcity and the Law of Opportunity Cost become irrelevant. Economics is based upon those two things, and when one declares they no longer are relevant, one no longer is an economist. In short, Paul Krugman tells us that government under the correct people (read that left-wing Democrats) can magically make scarcity and opportunity cost disappear.

Why? The Inflation Fairy says so.

Thursday, September 20, 2012

Disdain for Economics

I find it quite interesting that Paul Krugman has decided to recast himself as a populist, as though he is part of the "rest of us." (Anyone who has attended conferences and seen Krugman interacting with others can say quite assuredly that the guy hardly fits into the category of the "common man," especially since he is a multi-millionaire and an academic.)

As usual, in his latest column, he pretends to be Paul Krugman The Populist and excoriate Mitt Romney for his recent remarks at the Boca Raton fundraiser. What I find interesting, however, is that Krugman reverts to stereotypes, which hardly is what academics are supposed to do. Moreover, in other columns, he has claimed that inflation actually benefits the poor and middle class over the rich, which simply is not true.

Furthermore, instead of providing insight, Krugman provides Keynesian stereotypes. I find it interesting that Tim Carney, who hardly is a celebrated economist, gives much more insight into the whole Romney affair than Krugman ever could. Carney writes:
By tagging 47 percent of America as irresponsible, Obama-supporting government dependents, Romney showed again that his politics are grounded in false liberal premises.

Romney's statement at a closed-door fundraiser reflected the mistaken liberal view that the growth of government mostly redistributes wealth downward -- it doesn't. He also implicitly bought into the Left's narrow view that both tax cuts and welfare programs mostly benefit the immediate recipients. Finally, Romney conflated tax cuts with government aid, reflecting the perverse mindset that all wealth originally belongs to the state.
He then lays it out quite nicely:
Romney was correct that a portion of America backs President Obama because they "are dependent upon government" and "believe that they are entitled." We even know these dependents' names: Duke Energy CEO Jim Rogers, General Electric boss Jeff Immelt, Pfizer lobbying chief Sally Sussman, Solyndra investor George Kaiser and millionaire lobbyist Tony Podesta, to list a few.

In the last few years of bailouts, stimulus, Obamacare and government expansion in general, we have seen median income fall and corporate profits soar. Industries are consolidating as the big get bigger while the little guys shut down.
But it gets better:
When government controls more money, those with the best lobbyists pocket most of it. The five largest banks hold a share of U.S. assets 30 percent larger today than in 2006. Also, as Obama has expanded export subsidies, 75 percent of the Export-Import Bank's loan-guarantee dollars in the past three years have subsidized Boeing sales.

Romney, however, wasn't talking about corporate welfare queens. He was talking about the 47 percent of the population that pays no federal income tax.

Think about Romney's perverse logic here: He disparaged people as "dependent" for not owing income taxes. Many of these people are retired and living off the life savings they earned. A family of four earning $40,000 could owe zero federal income tax even without tax credits.

Keeping your own money isn't being "dependent on government." Sure, Obama speaks as if it were, lambasting the GOP for "giving" tax cuts to the wrong people. But Republicans are supposed to distinguish between government giving you something and government leaving you alone.
The real issue is not disdain for workers but rather disdain for investment and for economic growth. Romney certainly does not get it and neither does Krugman. (Nor does Obama, but we already knew that.) When I read Romney's quotes, all I can do is to shake my head, and when I read Krugman's quotes, I am reminded once again that he is a political operative, not an economist.

Monday, September 17, 2012

Hating on the Dollar

The late comedian David Frye, known best for his imitations of Richard Nixon, had an excellent monologue to mock Nixon's various economic programs, better known as Phase I, Phase II, and beyond. Frye's "Nixon" announced "Phase 23," a "going out of business sale." (One only could hope....)

Instead of Phase I and beyond, Ben Bernanke and his friends at the Fed have been giving us QE1, QE2, and now QE3, to go along with stimulus and "Operation Twist," more appropriately named by Peter Schiff as "Operation Screw." However, there are those who believe that the more the Fed tries to prop up worthless financial securities by debasing the dollar, the more the Fed is leading us to prosperity -- and anyone who disagrees is a "hater" or a near-criminal. Not surprisingly, Paul Krugman is in that group. He writes:
Mr. Romney’s (critical) language echoed that of the “liquidationists” of the 1930s, who argued against doing anything to mitigate the Great Depression. Until recently, the verdict on liquidationism seemed clear: it has been rejected and ridiculed not just by liberals and Keynesians but by conservatives too, including none other than Milton Friedman. “Aggressive monetary policy can reduce the depth of a recession,” declared the George W. Bush administration in its 2004 Economic Report of the President.
Being that I don't follow this presidential campaign much, I have no idea what Mitt Romney said in response to the latest Bernanke policy. I doubt seriously that Romney has a "plan" except to listen to his Neoconservative advisers like John Bolton and take us off to war again, with the idea that jacking up military spending will "boost" the economy.

One has to understand, however, that since 2001, the U.S. Government under both Bush and Obama have actively pursued an inflationary course, and in case one has not paid attention to the results, we are in a depression. (Oh, I forgot. The meltdown in 2008 came because the Regulation Fairies had been converted to free-market anarchism and failed to do any regulating. It had nothing to do with government and central bank policies to pump as much money into the housing market as possible, an action that was unsustainable.)

Like all good Keynesians, Krugman believes in the wonder and majesty of inflation. He declares:
The Fed’s response to this problem has been “quantitative easing,” a confusing term for buying assets other than Treasury bills, such as long-term U.S. debt. The hope has been that such purchases will drive down the cost of borrowing, and boost the economy even though conventional monetary policy has reached its limit.
Sure enough, last week’s Fed announcement included another round of quantitative easing, this time involving mortgage-backed securities. The big news, however, was the Fed’s declaration that “a highly accommodative stance of monetary policy will remain appropriate for a considerable time after the economic recovery strengthens.” In plain English, the Fed is more or less promising that it won’t start raising interest rates as soon as the economy looks better, that it will hold off until the economy is actually booming and (perhaps) until inflation has gone significantly higher. 
The idea here is that by indicating its willingness to let the economy rip for a while, the Fed can encourage more private-sector spending right away. Potential home buyers will be encouraged by the prospect of moderately higher inflation that will make their debt easier to repay; corporations will be encouraged by the prospect of higher future sales; stocks will rise, increasing wealth, and the dollar will fall, making U.S. exports more competitive.
In other words, the Fed goes into the markets, purchases securities that the market has declared to be near-worthless, spread dollars all over the place, and out of that will come a booming economy spreading prosperity wherever it may roam. This is about as credible as Aaron's reply to Moses about the shaping of the Golden Calf when Aaron claimed that he threw gold into a fire and the calf magically appeared.

This policy would work if an only if the economy were a mass of homogeneous factors. However, if factors of production are heterogeneous, and that a functioning price system, complete with profits and losses, is the means by which entrepreneurs do economic calculation, then the Keynesian "solution" is only making matters worse in the long run. There is no way around this point, and the longer the Fed and this government try to prop up worthless investments and the longer Bernanke and Obama try to divert scarce resources to those lines of production that are not profitable, then the longer this downturn will last.

Krugman's Keynesianism is based upon a belief that when the economy goes into a downturn, the Law of Opportunity Cost goes into hiatus. That is another way of saying that depressions make scarcity disappear and that the only thing needed is for more spending and more inflation, which will permit us to pretend we are wealthier than we are. Out of that faux wealth will come real wealth.

Get it? Yes, the only thing standing in the way is the dollar, and if we print it into oblivion, we will become rich.