Showing posts with label Gold. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gold. Show all posts

Friday, April 12, 2013

Lust for Lying

As I have written many times before, Paul Krugman no longer is an economist, if he ever was one. Instead, he is a political operative, someone who gives partisan political rants and pawns it off as Deep Economic Thinking.

His recent column on gold and people who favor it is more of the same, and he once again impugns the character of anyone who might disagree with him on the subject. It is not enough for Krugman to have an intellectual disagreement; no, to disagree with him is to be evil:
Conservative-minded people tend to support a gold standard — and to buy gold — because they’re very easily persuaded that “fiat money,” money created on a discretionary basis in an attempt to stabilize the economy, is really just part of the larger plot to take away their hard-earned wealth and give it to you-know-who.
No doubt, the "you-know-who" would be African-Americans or some other minority. You see, according to Krugman, to favor gold as money is to be a racist, someone who hates others. (Krugman is permitted to hate and spew out hatred because he is part of the Favored Political Classes that have the NYT stamp of approval.)

Also, anyone who does not believe in Krugman's Inflation Fairy does so out of hatred, prejudice, and evil.

Furthermore, to oppose Federal Reserve money printing and its QE Forever programs is also to be racist and diabolical. Why? Because Krugman says so.

Friday, August 24, 2012

Goldstein and Gold

I had no idea that Ayn Rand and John Gault ruled the Republican Party and Congress, but Paul Krugman claims that is so, and who can doubt what he says, given Krugman is always right about everything. So, today he claims that Paul Ryan is a devoted follower of Ayn Rand and that he is going to try to impose a gold coin standard upon us and destroy the economy.

Given that we have had Republicans talking about gold for decades, including Ronald Reagan and his Gold Commission, and it was a Republican, Richard Nixon, who destroyed the remnants of the American gold standard, somehow I don't think a guy who has read Atlas Shrugged a few times is going to end the paper money standard we have had for a while. However, all of us know that Goldstein is capable of anything, and no one depends more upon Goldstein that Krugman.

Yes, Krugman goes over the Usual Stuff on how Republicans always are going to completely end the Welfare State, even though Republicans in power never have done that. Well, Ryan did read some works by Ayn Rand, didn't he? What other proof do you need? Krugman writes:
Well, it’s right there in that 2005 speech to the Atlas Society, in which he declared that he always goes back to “Francisco d’Anconia’s speech on money” when thinking about monetary policy. Who? Never mind. That speech (which clocks in at a mere 23 paragraphs) is a case of hard-money obsession gone ballistic. Not only does the character in question, a Galt sidekick, call for a return to the gold standard, he denounces the notion of paper money and demands a return to gold coins.

But then Krugman gets into the meat of this column: Ryan will impose a gold standard, and the economy will collapse. This falls into the "Yeah, Right" Category. First, Krugman has been claiming that inflation will lead us into recovery, and he also has claimed that inflation is a wonderful way to transfer money from the wealthy to the poor. (Please tell that to the poor and lower-income people who have been spending more and more money at the gas pump and the grocery store that inflation is their savior.)

Second, Krugman claims that the inflation rate is so low that we really don't need to worry about money, anyway. So, what is it? Is inflation bad or good? If the rate is low, why doesn't he come out and claim that we need much more monetary debasement?

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Keynesianism: The (near) 80-year-old fallacy

One of the things that interests me about Paul Krugman is his use of the word "fallacy" when applied to economics. When I first was learning about economic fallacies, I was taught that they are committed when people believe they can circumvent or negate the Law of Scarcity and the Law of Opportunity Cost.

This was neatly expressed in the acronym TANSTAFL, or "There ain't no such thing as a free lunch." Today, however, it seems that economics, or at least the "economics" of Paul Krugman, has "evolved" and "progressed" well beyond opportunity cost. How do I know? Krugman himself has told us.

In a recent blog post, he makes some interesting, if not outrageous, statements. (Come to think of it, Krugman makes lots and lots of outrageous statements.) He declares:
...when I was younger I firmly believed that economics was a field that progressed over time, that every generation knew more than the generation before.

The question now is whether that’s still true. In 1971 it was clear that economists knew a lot that they hadn’t known in 1931. Is that clear when we compare 2011 with 1971? I think you can actually make the case that in important ways the profession knew more in 1971 than it does now.
What happened in 1971? The U.S. Dollar collapsed as President Richard Nixon declared that suddenly it had come "under attack" by those evil "speculators." Nixon said nothing about the fact that the government, through the Federal Reserve System, had inflated the dollar for years in order to pay for the Great Society and the Vietnam War, and at the same time offering gold from the treasury to foreign governments at $35 an ounce.

Not surprisingly, U.S. gold reserves were fast dwindling and there was a run on the dollar itself, so Nixon did as one might expect Nixon to do: he blamed others and failed to tell the truth about what really was happening. Furthermore, he slapped down general wage and price controls in order to try to keep consumer prices from escalating.

Nixon had the public support of a lot of economists, even those who knew that his "economic plan" (then called Phase I) would be an inflationary disaster -- and it was. What economists "knew" in 1971, if one looks at the actions of the Fed and the president's economic advisers, was that government could inflate its way out of trouble, and the government could manage the economy through various edicts.

This was the day when John Kenneth Galbraith was the king of American economists, along with Paul Samuelson. Of course, what these men "knew" turned out to be utterly untrue. Government could not inflate its way out of trouble, and the 1970s, a decade when the U.S. economy lurched from one crisis to another, proved it.

However, I suspect that Krugman would have us believe that the price controls were brilliant, that all of the problems of the dollar in 1971 were due to speculators, and that had the government left price controls on everything, we would have enjoyed unparalleled prosperity. Or something like that.

His next statement, however, is a Classic Krugman Howler:
I’ve written a lot about the Dark Age of macroeconomics, of the way economists are recapitulating 80-year-old fallacies in the belief that they’re profound insights, because they’re ignorant of the hard-won insights of the past.

What I’d add to that is that at this point it seems to me that many economists aren’t even trying to get at the truth. When I look at a lot of what prominent economists have been writing in response to the ongoing economic crisis, I see no sign of intellectual discomfort, no sense that a disaster their models made no allowance for is troubling them; I see only blithe invention of stories to rationalize the disaster in a way that supports their side of the partisan divide. And no, it’s not symmetric: liberal economists by and large do seem to be genuinely wrestling with what has happened, but conservative economists don’t.
And what is the "enlightened" viewpoint? Why it is print money, bail out everyone, continue the fraud of heavily-subsidized "green energy" that Krugman and his friends insist will lead us to recovery, and have the federal government hire millions of people to engage in make work.

Now, since the General Theory was published first in 1936, it is only a 75-year-old fallacy. The "80-year-old "fallacies" apparently are things like the Law of Scarcity and the Law of Opportunity Cost. In Krugman's view, it is "progress" simply to say that when the economy is in recession, Opportunity Cost no longer holds, and that government can alleviate or even do away with Scarcity via the printing press.

Furthermore, Krugman has made it clear that anyone who might actually appeal to those "80-year-old fallacies" is immoral and has no conscience. Yeah, Krugman and the Really Smart People have done away with Scarcity simply by declaring it no longer exists, at least when government prints up the money.

Keynesianism is one big fallacy, and a cult fallacy at that. It violates the Law of Cause and Effect by declaring that effect really is cause. And it wants us to assume that work is nothing more than a transmission mechanism for money, and it does not matter what government pays people to do, just as long as it provides money so that they can spend it and make us prosperous.

This isn't economics. It is nonsense.

Thursday, August 25, 2011

Space aliens and coal mines: yeah, it all makes sense, now!

When I taught a macro course 20 years ago at UT-Chattanooga, we used Wallace Peterson's book which quoted Keynes as though it were Holy Scripture. Not surprisingly, Paul Krugman now seeks to justify his "space aliens" nonsense with...a quote from (Who else?) Keynes.

I will let readers view his post, but keep in mind that Krugman also thinks that he has effectively demolished the idea of gold being legitimate money. (According to Krugman, gold is a "useless metal," which I suspect is his way of saying that people use scarce resources to dig up something "useless," which, I guess, means that they are idiots.)

Furthermore, the use of gold bars in the "basements of central banks" is a relatively recent phenomenon and has little to do with the historical role of gold being used as a medium of exchange as opposed to a basis for issuing paper. But, given what I have read of Krugman, he would take it that we should leave gold in the ground (except for jewelry) because paper is being managed by Really Smart and Serious People like Ben Bernanke.

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Gold at $1600? Paul Krugman says it is a nefarious plot by Glenn Beck!

One of Paul Krugman's constant themes is that the U.S. economy is in a liquidity trap and the only way out is for the government to borrow and spend trillions of dollars. (In other words, if we are not prosperous, we spend as though we are, and the debt created through this scheme magically will take care of itself.)

Of course, a liquidity trap also means deflation, as the normal central bank tool of cutting interest rates to stimulate private borrowing cannot work, as interest rates are too low. Thus, the only way out is through massive government spending.

There is a problem with all of this, however, and that is the fact that not only are food and fuel prices rising, but also other commodity prices, including gold, silver and platinum. What's a Keynesian to do?

Well, since Krugman is in that Princeton group with Ben Bernanke and Alan Blinder, all of which utterly disdain gold and believe that anyone who would buy it as an inflation hedge is a "nut case," I was wondering how The Great One would handle the fact that gold prices have skyrocketed.

(As for the rising price of food and fuel, Krugman on many occasions has blamed the rise on "volatility" or demand from other countries. Since he has declared that there can be no inflation in a liquidity trap, the whole matter is settled -- by definition.)

As always, Krugman fails to disappoint. This time we see that the rise in gold prices is the result of a nefarious plot by...Glenn Beck. After quoting at length from The Street Light, which proclaims that gold prices have "nothing to do with the economy," Krugman declares:
Glenn Beck was financially intertwined with Goldline, and therefore had a financial stake in pushing fears of hyperinflation. And he had many, many viewers. So there was a direct channel through which conservative Americans were being pushed into buying gold.

Market prices almost always tell you something useful. But sometimes what they tell you is that there’s a marketing scam in progress.
Here is the problem with Krugman's analysis: if Glenn Beck and his friends are secretly buying gold in order to entice other people to buy it so that the price will go up well past its fundamentals, they are playing a dangerous game with their own money.

Remember the Hunt Brothers in the late 1970s when they tried to corner the world market on silver? In the short run, they drove the price to nearly $50 an ounce before the whole scheme collapsed. The biggest losers were the Hunts, who lost big when silver dropped to about $11 an ounce in two months (after the scheme was exposed), and then were driven into bankruptcy in 1988 after investors filed numerous lawsuits against them.

Now, I am no expert in buying gold or other commodities, but I don't think that Glenn Beck or any other investor is secretly manipulating the price of gold or anything else. Inflation is a real possibility, given the fact that the U.S. Government has been sending dollars around the globe in an attempt to paper over the financial weaknesses both of banks and central banks. Krugman's insistence that debasing the dollar is the key to prosperity does not exactly give me confidence that I should follow his investment advice and buy government bonds.

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Is "Volatility" the Last Refuge of a Scoundrel? (Or At Least a Keynesian?)

To "prove" his argument that commodity prices and inflation have no relationship, Krugman has a blog post in which he uses the graph below.


The problem is this: Which commodities? We have seen prices of gold skyrocket, although Krugman would regard gold as passe or even evil. But an even more important bellwether would be oil prices, since oil worldwide is denominated in U.S. Dollars. Thus, oil might well be more sensitive to changes in the value of the dollar than might other commodities.

In other words, de-homogenization might be something worthwhile here. Just a thought.

The second problem I see is that once again, Krugman uses the deus ex machina explanation of "volatility" to explain away anything that might be uncomfortable. Are oil and gold prices going up? Well, so what? They are volatile; that explains everything.

Thursday, December 23, 2010

Krugman: Print Money! Print More Money!!

In The Return of Depression Economics (which I reviewed here), Paul Krugman writes: “Recessions, in other words, can be fought simply by printing money—and can sometimes (usually) be cured with surprising ease.”

Once upon a time, printing money was another euphemism for inflation, but in this day of Orwellian Newspeak, it is called "Quantitative Easing" or something else. (Krugman holds that inflation is measured only by indexes, so just creating more money in and of itself is meaningless.) Furthermore, according to Krugman, real-live evidence of inflation is, well, irrelevant whenever Krugman says so. He recently wrote:
For two years we’ve been warned that inflation, even hyperinflation, was just around the corner; instead, disinflation has continued, with core inflation — which excludes volatile food and energy prices — now at a half-century low. (Emphasis mine)
In other words, two situations in which you really will be feeling the brunt of higher prices is nothing more than volatility at work. However, does anyone really think that food prices will be volatile downward anytime soon?

This is part of the "heads I win, tails you lose" arguing style that Krugman employs. Housing prices have been depressed for a long time, but they were way out of kilter and even Krugman will admit that, and that has had an effect upon the price indexes.

What Krugman does not say, however, is that food, energy, and commodities in general are quite sensitive to changes in the value of money and often act as the proverbial canary in the coal mine. Because Krugman hates gold and silver (or any other kind of "hard" money) and commodities in general, anything that might reflect the fact that people are escaping the dollar and buying something that can hold its value relative to money is something that is evil.

(Of course, anyone who disagrees with Krugman on this subject is a "zombie" and not even worthy of being permitted to inhabit the same planet as Krugman.)

So, inflation is the key in Krugman's view. Save the world by flooding it with dollars or whatever, but flood the world.